semantic-scala
Local stdio MCP server with eight bounded tools for Scala compilation, tests, compiler diagnostics, type/effect summaries, symbols, SemanticDB, and evidence reconciliation for AI coding agents.
Documentation
scala-semantic-harness
Experimental semantic tooling for Scala and functional-programming projects used by coding agents.
The harness is a bounded semantic evidence layer, not a replacement for the
Scala compiler, sbt, tests, Metals, or other IDE/LSP tooling. Compiler, build,
and test results remain the final correctness oracle. See
docs/project-status.md for current evidence and
readiness limits and
docs/semantic-tooling-positioning.md
for the product boundary. Technical evaluators can use
docs/early-feedback.md to report a concrete
real-project comparison.
The current tree is the standalone experimental public-alpha source product under the Apache-2.0 license. It was published from an independently constructed, audited clean root followed only by reviewed public-product commits. The earlier mixed development history is retained separately in a private archive and is not part of this public repository.
Mutable source main reports 0.1.0-alpha.4-SNAPSHOT for source development
only. No Alpha 4 Central artifact, supported channel, tag, GitHub Release, or
release-readiness claim is established.
The exact eight-module 0.1.0-alpha.3 release is published on Maven Central,
and the public main two-application Coursier channel selects it. Fresh
outsider-like JDK 21 install/runtime/update/uninstall through the actual public
raw-GitHub URL and Maven Central passed, as did commit-pinned reproduction.
Both exact Alpha 2 and Alpha 3 application routes now have bounded supported-
distribution READY evidence. The immutable 0.1.0-alpha.3 lightweight tag
identifies commit 075a60bfb7d7677d7fdfcc2369c9ffe41c8b32a8, whose two clean
builds reproduced all 32 public Maven primaries. Its
GitHub prerelease
has normal generated source archives plus the exact Linux x86_64 MCPB used by
the active official Registry record. The immutable
0.1.0-alpha.2 tag and prerelease retain the independently qualified supported
route and source identity for its 32 Central primaries.
Agent quick start
The current supported packaged route is exact 0.1.0-alpha.3 on JDK 21. Install the
CLI and generic stdio MCP server first:
cs install --default-channels=false \
--channel https://raw.githubusercontent.com/DmytroMitin/scala-semantic-harness/main/distribution/coursier/channel.json \
semantic-scala semantic-scala-mcp
semantic-scala version
Then choose the integration that the agent client supports: the complete CLI,
the curated exact-eight MCP projection, and/or the immutable alpha-2 agent
skill. Copying this repository's thin skill wrappers into another project is
not supported; install the canonical skill from the 0.1.0-alpha.2 tag.
docs/agent-onboarding.md gives copy-ready Codex,
Claude Code, Cursor, and VS Code/Copilot recipes, exact local qualification
statuses, skill installation, the CLI/MCP surface matrix, and troubleshooting.
Alpha-3 project and target-JDK selectors are explicitly excluded from the
alpha-2 packaged contract. The qualified mutable main channel selects Alpha 3;
Alpha 2 remains reproducible through its immutable tag-pinned channel.
What is included
- structured compile, test, and diagnostic reports;
- SemanticDB inventory, coverage, symbol, and exact-symbol usage evidence;
- bounded Presentation Compiler symbol and type queries;
- reconciliation of dynamic compiler evidence with an explicit SemanticDB artifact;
- a public point-evidence composition that preserves source-artifact discovery, safe selection, live symbol evidence, and conditional reconciliation;
- Alpha 3 opt-in build-target-aware SemanticDB source mapping v4 with a validated optional Scala axis and root-only receipt, alongside target-aware point-evidence v4 with a non-compiling partial existing-output context and explicit v5 existing-internal-Compile-output opt-in, plus strict v6 content-fresh internal-output gating;
- an Alpha 3 CLI-only, same-request post-compile TASTy point-evidence operation with exact stable Scala 3 child-inspector provenance;
- bounded Alpha 3 sbt-backed command, classpath, and TASTy-receipt compatibility proven on sbt 1.12.15 and 2.0.6 fixtures;
- conservative syntax-first FP effect summaries;
- a stdio MCP server exposing exactly eight public tools;
- small external example projects and benchmark infrastructure; and
- a client-neutral
semantic-scalaagent skill with thin Codex and Claude Code wrappers; - source templates and a deterministic assembler for a self-contained Agent Plugins 1.0 package containing that skill and the exact-eight MCP server; and
- a supported, independently qualified exact-eight Maven/Coursier application
route for exact versions
0.1.0-alpha.2and0.1.0-alpha.3, with Alpha 3 current on the publicmainchannel and Alpha 2 retained at its release tag.
Modules
modules/core: shared JSON models and codecs.modules/cli: thesemantic-scalacommand entry point.modules/sbt-runner: sbt compile/test subprocess integration.modules/semanticdb-reader: SemanticDB inventory and usage evidence.modules/presentation-compiler: bounded dynamic semantic queries.modules/semantic-reconciliation: static/dynamic symbol comparison and the point-evidence composition and reconciliation contracts.modules/fp-analyzers: syntax-first effect summaries.modules/mcp-server: CLI-backed MCP stdio adapter.modules/benchmark: benchmark models and fixtures.
Build and test
The project uses Scala 3 and sbt. A fresh source setup requires JDK 21, sbt, Git, and Python 3; CI uses Temurin JDK 21. A newer local JDK may work, but it is not the documented baseline.
Scala 3 describes the harness implementation, not a blanket target-language
promise. A bounded JDK 21 matrix has verified build/test/error delegation,
SemanticDB discovery/symbol/usages, and syntax-first effect summaries on Scala
2.13.18 and Scala 3.3.8 fixtures. The harness is built with Scala 3.9.0 and its
dynamic point operations use the linked Scala 3.9.0 Presentation Compiler.
That host compiler resolved the matrix's shared-syntax Scala 2 points, but this
is not general Scala 2 dialect or compiler support. Target builds still use
their selected target compiler; static SemanticDB and post-compile TASTy
evidence remain target-artifact evidence. Reconciliation and point evidence
inherit the dynamic-source limitation. See
docs/project-status.md and
docs/semantic-api.md for the exact boundary.
Two maintained real-project Stage-A checks now cover frozen Scala 2.13.18
revisions without source or build changes. scala/scala-java8-compat produced
no SemanticDB, so its otherwise-passing alpha-2 matrix preserved truthful
degraded point evidence. A bounded production row of scalacenter/scalafix
produced target-owned SemanticDB; static symbol discovery, bounded dynamic
lookup, exact static/dynamic reconciliation, complete point evidence, and the
ordered exact-eight MCP projection passed. Scalafix's aggregated sbt build also
exposed that the alpha-2 build oracle cannot select one project row. The
Alpha 3 release closes that routing gap with an optional validated
project selector; the immutable alpha-2 distribution remains unchanged. These
two projects are complementary bounded evidence, not general Scala 2 support or
semantic superiority.
The Alpha 3 release sbt subprocess boundary sends project selection plus
one product-owned task as a single fixed command sequence. Its injected
classpath/receipt adapters use sbt's fileConverter for sbt 2 virtual
references and preserve sbt 1 file-backed entries. Readable extensionless sbt 2
CAS JARs are copied directly, without cache scanning, into an owner-only
content-addressed area under the selected workspace's generated target tree.
A disposable sbt 2.0.6 fixture, a disposable sbt 2.0.7 multi-project fixture,
frozen sbt 1.12.15 and sbt 2.0.6 plugin projects, and a frozen Chimney sbt
2.0.7 / Scala 3.8.4 selected row pass their bounded gates. The shared runner
uses a request-owned foreground sbt server lifecycle, and structured sbt suite
counters preserve ignored/skipped tests in the existing Test JSON fields. This
is version-specific evidence, not universal sbt 2 or compiler-plugin
compatibility. Chimney's macro-heavy PC points remain neutrally unresolved
because target compiler options and plugins are not replayed.
sbt -batch test
sbt cli/stage
sbt mcpServer/stage
The source-checkout wrapper runs the CLI through sbt:
./semantic-scala --help
./semantic-scala version
./semantic-scala compile --json
./semantic-scala compile --sbt-project core2_13 --json
./semantic-scala compile --sbt-project plugin --sbt-java-home /absolute/path/to/installed-jdk --json
./semantic-scala test --json
./semantic-scala errors --json
compile, errors, test, semanticdb-for-source, and point-evidence
accept an optional --sbt-project <id> where
the ID matches [A-Za-z][A-Za-z0-9_-]*. Without it they preserve ordinary root
behavior. With it, compile/errors run that project's fixed Compile scope and
test runs its fixed Test scope. The selector is not arbitrary sbt syntax, and
a successful selected invocation proves only that bounded project operation,
not whole-workspace correctness.
All eight sbt-backed forms (compile, errors, test, target-aware
semanticdb-for-source, target-aware point-evidence, sbt-backed infer-type,
infer-type-batch, and tasty-point-evidence) also accept an
optional --sbt-java-home <absolute-directory>. The harness itself remains on the
supported JDK 21 runtime; only the target sbt child receives the selected
canonical JAVA_HOME and a matching PATH prefix. The home must already be
installed and pass bounded validation and a fixed version probe. The harness
does not discover, download, install, or globally select JDKs. Omitting the
flag preserves inherited-Java behavior. Selected-JDK classpath acquisition is
isolated from no-selector cache reuse, and public result schemas do not expose
the home or probe evidence.
Target-aware semanticdb-for-source and point-evidence also accept
--sbt-scala-version <version>. The option requires --sbt-project, uses a
strict version-only grammar, and selects that cross-Scala axis in a fresh sbt
lifecycle. Source mapping then runs its fixed root-only receipt task; point
evidence runs its distinct partial existing-output point-context receipt.
Omission means the checked-in build default, never inherited ++ state.
For repeated use, prefer the staged launcher at
modules/cli/target/stage/bin/semantic-scala.
Maven/Coursier distribution
The source-build route above remains supported and externally verified. Exact
eight-module Alpha 2 and Alpha 3 runtimes are published under final group
com.github.dmytromitin on Maven Central, with their complete public repository
shapes verified against reviewed bytes. Both exact versions passed fresh
outsider-like public raw-GitHub install/runtime/update/uninstall against Maven
Central only. Alpha 3 is current on main and also passed commit-pinned
reproduction; Alpha 2 retains its immutable, qualified release-tag route.
The Central publication contains exactly the eight implementation modules,
never the root aggregate or benchmark, and the public channel uses
exact-version descriptors for the
distinct semantic-scala CLI and semantic-scala-mcp server applications.
JDK 21 and Coursier are runtime/install prerequisites. Target-workspace sbt is
needed by build-oracle commands such as compile, errors, and test; it is
not required merely to install the applications or for every read-only
semantic command. The Maven modules are application implementation artifacts,
not a supported embeddable-library API or binary-compatibility promise.
Install only the CLI:
cs install --default-channels=false \
--channel https://raw.githubusercontent.com/DmytroMitin/scala-semantic-harness/main/distribution/coursier/channel.json \
semantic-scala
Or install the CLI and stdio MCP server together:
cs install --default-channels=false \
--channel https://raw.githubusercontent.com/DmytroMitin/scala-semantic-harness/main/distribution/coursier/channel.json \
semantic-scala semantic-scala-mcp
Use semantic-scala-mcp as the generic stdio MCP command with the target
workspace as its working directory. See
docs/distribution.md for Coursier setup, updates,
uninstall, commit-pinned channel reproduction, and the current qualification
boundary.
Semantic commands
./semantic-scala semanticdb-status --workspace . --json
./semantic-scala semanticdb-coverage --workspace . --json
./semantic-scala semanticdb-for-source --file src/main/scala/example/Main.scala --workspace . --json
./semantic-scala point-evidence --file src/main/scala/example/Main.scala --workspace . --line 6 --col 16 --json
./semantic-scala semanticdb-for-source --file src/main/scala/example/Main.scala --workspace . --sbt-project app [--sbt-scala-version 3.3.7] --json
./semantic-scala point-evidence --file src/main/scala/example/Main.scala --workspace . --line 6 --col 16 --sbt-project app [--sbt-scala-version 3.3.7] [--include-existing-internal-outputs [--require-fresh-internal-outputs]] --json
./semantic-scala tasty-point-evidence --workspace . --sbt-project app --file src/main/scala/example/Main.scala --line 6 --col 16 [--sbt-java-home /absolute/path/to/installed-jdk] --json
./semantic-scala symbols --semanticdb path/to/Main.scala.semanticdb --json
./semantic-scala usages --workspace . --manifest semantic-usages.json --symbol 'example/Foo#bar().' --json
./semantic-scala symbol-at --file path/to/Main.scala --line 6 --col 16 --json
./semantic-scala infer-type --file path/to/Main.scala --line 6 --col 16 --json
./semantic-scala infer-type-batch --requests batch-request.json --workspace . --sbt-project core --sbt-configuration Compile [--sbt-java-home /absolute/path/to/installed-jdk] --json
./semantic-scala reconcile-symbol --file path/to/Main.scala --line 6 --col 16 --semanticdb path/to/Main.scala.semanticdb --json
./semantic-scala effect-summary --file path/to/UserRepo.scala --json
Target-aware source mapping and point evidence are explicit Alpha 3
options. Omitting target options preserves the v2 workspace-wide behavior,
including truthful ambiguity. With --sbt-project, source mapping emits v4 and
uses a fixed root-only Compile receipt containing target identity,
classDirectory, semanticdbTargetRoot, requested/effective Scala-axis
provenance, and bounded JDK provenance. It does not request target compilation,
fullClasspath, products, or exported products; sbt build/plugin loading,
resolution, and ordinary metadata/cache writes remain possible. Candidate
ownership is checked canonically beneath the reported SemanticDB root while
workspace discovery remains unchanged. Optional --sbt-scala-version selects
one validated axis and must exactly match the effective receipt axis; omission
uses the fresh lifecycle's build default.
Target-aware point evidence emits v4 by default. It acquires exactly one fixed Compile
receipt containing the selected existing class directory when present plus the
selected target's external dependencies. It never requests target compilation,
fullClasspath, products, or exported products, and has no build fallback.
The report always marks this context PartialExistingOutputs; a missing class
directory is omitted rather than built. Checked-in sbt build/plugin loading,
dependency resolution, and metadata/cache writes remain possible. The harness
Presentation Compiler does not replay target compiler flags, plugins, or
lifecycle, and the context is not a complete arbitrary multi-project classpath.
An explicit --include-existing-internal-outputs presence flag emits v5 and
adds only already-present same-axis internal Compile class directories found by
a bounded settings-only dependency traversal. Missing outputs remain typed and
are never built. V5 stays PartialExistingCompileOutputs, does not request
fullClasspath, products, or internalDependencyClasspath, and still does not
replay target compiler flags/plugins. The existing eighth MCP tool exposes the
same opt-in as optional boolean includeExistingInternalOutputs; the registry
remains exactly eight.
Adding --require-fresh-internal-outputs requires the v5 flag and emits v6.
It reads only existing same-axis Compile / compileAnalysisFile archives and
uses supported Zinc persistence APIs in one on-demand bounded JDK 21 worker
plus content stamps and source/product relations. The worker is not resolved
or launched by v2/v4/v5 or ordinary MCP initialization. Its exact pinned Zinc
1.12.1/Scala 2.13.18/JNA 5.14.0 graph is cache-first; first uncached strict-v6
use may contact Maven Central and populate the Coursier cache, while a warm
cache can run offline. Cold offline unavailability fails closed as
Unverifiable, with no compile or linked-runtime fallback. The same settings-only receipt captures exact configured source
roots and generator-list cardinality; configured generators, managed source
residue, unavailable provenance, unsafe roots, or exceeded file/archive bounds
fail closed as Unverifiable. Only internal directories proven Fresh
contribute; Stale and all Unverifiable states remain visible but excluded.
This does not compile, run generators, use mtimes or Git state as freshness
authority, or establish whole-target/build freshness. The matching MCP boolean is
requireFreshInternalOutputs on the same eighth tool.
Moving the graph off normal process classpaths reduces the ordinary staged and
shipped dependency surface; it does not claim lower total disk use after the
on-demand cache has been populated.
semanticdb-for-source remains CLI-only, direct reconcile-symbol remains an
explicit-artifact target-independent operation, and the MCP registry remains
exactly eight tools.
All machine-facing commands have JSON output. Build-oracle command exit code
0 means the CLI operation completed; inspect the JSON success field for the
compile or test domain result. Semantic results preserve their scope and
uncertainty: rendered hover text is not canonical identity, artifact presence
is not complete source coverage, and only ExactMatch is exact reconciliation.
Detailed contracts:
docs/semantic-api.mddocs/usages.mddocs/point-evidence.mddocs/tasty-point-evidence.mddocs/architecture.md
MCP server
The stdio server exposes exactly these tools:
semantic_compile
semantic_errors
semantic_test
semantic_effect_summary
semantic_symbol_at
semantic_symbols
semantic_reconcile_symbol
semantic_point_evidence
Build and validate it with:
sbt cli/stage
sbt mcpServer/stage
scripts/mcp/smoke-mcp-tools.py
Copy .mcp.example.json and replace its placeholder
checkout path for source-development client configuration. Installed alpha-2
users should configure semantic-scala-mcp directly. See
docs/mcp-client-validation.md for the public
configuration and protocol checks and
docs/agent-onboarding.md for client recipes.
Agent skill
The canonical client-neutral policy is
skills/semantic-scala/SKILL.md. Thin
repository wrappers live at:
These files are source-tree wrappers, not standalone external installations.
The skill is policy and documentation. It does not add commands, background
services, or automatic invocation. External alpha-2 installation plus client
qualification is in
docs/agent-onboarding.md; packaging and
maintenance guidance is in
docs/agent-skill-semantic-scala.md.
For a current repository-sourced installation, select the single canonical skill explicitly:
npx skills add https://github.com/DmytroMitin/scala-semantic-harness --skill semantic-scala
This installs guidance only; install the supported runtime separately. The
qualified command, stable catalog metadata, registry boundaries, and native
plugin follow-ups are documented in
docs/discoverability.md.
Official MCP Registry package
The repository includes a deterministic MCPB packaging surface for the exact
0.1.0-alpha.3 CLI and MCP server. The published Linux x86_64 package carries a
package-local Corretto 21 runtime and static entry points, so it does not call
an undeclared host java. It preserves ordinary host access to the target
Scala workspace and its build tools. Qualification is limited to Linux x86_64
with a compatible GNU-libc environment and system zlib; it is not a claim for
every Linux libc or distribution.
The exact bundle is a public Alpha-3 release asset and its active official MCP
Registry record is io.github.DmytroMitin/semantic-scala. The maintained
manifest and final record are under packaging/mcpb/semantic-scala/ and
distribution/mcp-registry/. See
docs/mcpb-package.md for the immutable URL and digest,
exact-tag build, determinism, validation, and platform boundary.
Agent Plugin package
After staging the CLI and MCP server, generate a fresh relocatable package:
sbt cli/stage mcpServer/stage
python3 scripts/package-agent-plugin.py assemble \
--output target/agent-plugin/semantic-scala
python3 scripts/package-agent-plugin.py validate \
--plugin-root target/agent-plugin/semantic-scala
The output is ignored build material, not a checked-in binary distribution or
release. It targets the Agent Plugins 1.0.0 working draft and bundles the
canonical skill, complete staged CLI, and complete staged exact-eight MCP
server. See docs/agent-plugin.md for the package
contract, validation level, relocation smoke, and current client-support
limits.
Native plugin candidates
The repository also contains deterministic OpenAI/Codex and Claude Code source
templates plus an assembler that transforms the exact published Alpha-3 MCPB
into native candidates with a package-local Java runtime. Both candidates
passed native manifest validation, canonical-skill byte checks, two-build
inventory equality, and a relocated no-host-Java exact-eight runtime smoke.
Codex CLI 0.154.0 additionally passed a disposable local-marketplace install,
skill load, bundled-MCP registration, and one read-only semantic call. Claude
Code 2.1.220 passed a disposable local-marketplace install, packaged-skill
load, plugin-local MCP connection, and one read-only client-mediated semantic
call after an explicit owner login checkpoint. The historical full Claude
candidate remains preserved at commit
c05aac9f38e7755a51f511078ff555a587f97ccf in
DmytroMitin/semantic-scala-claude-plugin,
and the rejected thin wrapper remains at
05d4f0de35a02916504bf29156bc42270cf77a23. The existing draft was submitted
once on 28 September 2026. Its current status is Needs changes: the reviewer
does not allow a Directory plugin to download and execute server code from a
GitHub Release after installation, even when checksum-pinned. Public main now
contains the skills-only source described below.
The locally qualified no-download candidate is maintained under packaging/claude-embedded-plugin/ and embeds a compact local MCPB directly in the plugin. It has no post-install executable fetch or updater. The runtime remains Alpha-3 while the prepared plugin distribution version is 0.1.0-alpha.3.1. The deterministic MCPB is 145,197,017 bytes, expands to 181,937,037 bytes across 1,952 files, and has SHA-256 6c1c698eaa73b78b9d005cbba4fccffd2e357e721e7f64fbeccdb13bb723d4ed. The six-file ZIP is 144,399,347 bytes, expands to 145,233,144 bytes, and has SHA-256 9004bfa94a3e60618430092bd253ac6354aa64290c3ebad41c2a8f3a6999f2d6. Official MCPB and Claude plugin validation, three byte-identical builds, the full exact-eight compatibility suite, and one isolated installed-client semantic call pass. The candidate is nevertheless blocked for the public Directory: the current pre-submission checklist requires the GitHub archive to be under 50 MiB and every plugin file under 5 MiB. The distribution repository, portal version, submission, and public listing remain unchanged.
A separate contained Claude Directory candidate is maintained under
packaging/claude-directory-skills-only-plugin/.
It contains only metadata, one small execution skill, a byte-identical copy of
the canonical policy, documentation, license, and deterministic inventory. It
declares no MCP/CLI runtime, hook, LSP, executable, installer, updater, or
allowed-tools; Claude Code uses an independently installed semantic-scala
through its ordinary shell permission path. Plugin distribution version
0.1.0-alpha.3.2 keeps exact CLI prerequisite 0.1.0-alpha.3. The six-file
source is 41,500 bytes and its deterministic ZIP is 16,392 bytes. Strict plugin
validation, contained-package checks, the direct CLI prerequisite matrix, and
authenticated installed-client effect-summary, build-backed, missing-CLI,
no-tool, and surface cases pass. The exact source is public at distribution
commit f28fe7a61ff449c9775d554d5bc9a11e2a9cfda1; its 18,708-byte GitHub archive
passes every current hard limit. The existing submission remains Needs changes and still resolves rejected commit 05d4f0d because the portal offers
no source refresh without resubmission. No resubmission or listing occurred.
See
docs/claude-directory-skills-only-plugin.md.
The owner packet under
distribution/claude-community/ records the
immutable qualification commit and expected human review hold. The
owner-approved semantic-scala Privacy Policy is public and
exposed from the qualified plugin README. The submitted answers are Reads only, No, Not retained, and No; all four compliance acknowledgements
were owner-approved. The private contact value is not retained in this
repository.
A separate OpenAI skills-only candidate now lives under
packaging/openai-skills-plugin/ without
reusing or changing the local-MCP candidate. It packages one narrow read-only
effect-summary workflow, an exact canonical-policy reference, and a
standard-library-only Python helper. The helper fetches and verifies the fixed
Alpha-3 runtime on first approved use, then invokes bin/semantic-scala
directly; it contains no MCP configuration and starts no MCP process. Codex CLI
0.157.1 passed disposable marketplace installation, installed-skill loading,
packaged-helper invocation, and interpretation of Fixture.value: Option[Int].
Cold acquisition and warm cache-only reuse passed with unchanged fixture bytes.
This is local technical qualification, not an OpenAI submission or public
listing. Current OpenAI guidance requires partner contact before submitting
the local-execution/local-file/offline workflow. The inspected first-party
material exposes no generic actionable contact route, so eligibility remains
unknown and no Platform draft was created. One original square SVG is
owner-approved and wired to both branding fields. The public privacy policy
covers the OpenAI/Codex path, first-use download, and separate cache. See
docs/openai-skills-only-plugin.md.
The earlier thin candidate remains documented as reviewer-rejected historical evidence in docs/claude-directory-thin-plugin.md. It must not be resubmitted unchanged. See docs/claude-directory-embedded-plugin.md for the locally qualified, no-download package, exact identities, current Claude limits, and the resulting public-Directory blocker. Do not publish this candidate as a Directory source without resolving that blocker.
Examples and benchmarks
Projects under examples/ are external CLI fixtures rather than members of
the root sbt build. The normal test suite exercises the compile-success and
compile-failure examples through the CLI.
The repository contains a standalone public benchmark subset with methodology,
portable prompts, test-coupled fixtures, deterministic validation, and a
bounded aggregate. Start at benchmarks/README.md.
Historical raw transcripts and controller automation are not part of that
subset. The admitted evidence does not establish broad superiority or general
benchmark reproducibility beyond its stated small-sample gate.
Current limitations
- The official MCPB package is validated only for Linux x86_64. Other operating systems and architectures require separately built and tested assets. The tested bundle requires a compatible GNU-libc environment and system zlib even though it requires no host Java.
- A generated self-contained Agent Plugins package has bounded structural, official-schema, determinism, and relocated-runtime evidence, but no supported release channel or conformant installed-client adoption proof.
- The OpenAI/Codex and Claude Code native packages are locally validated Linux x86_64 candidates assembled from the exact Alpha-3 MCPB. Both have bounded disposable installed-client skill and MCP-use qualification. They are not public listings or supported public install channels. OpenAI public MCP submission still requires a separately authorized public HTTPS service. The Claude thin source at 05d4f0de35a02916504bf29156bc42270cf77a23 is reviewer-rejected because it downloads executable server bytes after installation. The embedded MCPB removes that download, preserves package-local Java, and passes the full exact-eight compatibility suite plus one isolated client semantic call. It fits the separate 200 MB claude.ai upload rules, but not the public Directory checklist: its 144,399,347-byte GitHub archive exceeds 50 MiB and its 145,197,017-byte MCPB exceeds the 5 MiB per-file limit. The Directory plugin route is therefore blocked pending a different architecture or an explicit reviewer-approved mechanism.
- The separate eight-file OpenAI skills-only candidate is locally validated on
Codex CLI
0.157.1for one direct-CLIeffect-summaryworkflow with no MCP dependency. It is not submitted. OpenAI product-specific review has no discoverable official generic contact route, so eligibility remains unknown. The shared logo/composer SVG is owner-approved and locally validated. Verified publisher identity, Apps Management write access, country selection, and policy attestations remain prerequisites; privacy is public. - The MCP surface remains the documented eight-tool stdio adapter.
- Source-paired
semanticdb-for-source,point-evidence, andreconcile-symbolrequests now report snapshot-consistent content freshness. Fresh means the captured source content agrees with the captured SemanticDB document; it does not mean a build ran or that the whole project compiles. - Stale SemanticDB remains visible but cannot produce completed reconciliation. Unverifiable evidence stays explicit and can complete only as qualified evidence. SemanticDB inventory and coverage still do not establish that every source is covered or fresh.
- Presentation Compiler renderings are bounded evidence, not whole-project compile proof.
- The canonical skill selects
symbol-atfor one exact Presentation Compiler declaration question and reservespoint-evidencefor questions where artifact discovery/selection and reconciliation are themselves relevant. Source-sufficient questions still require no semantic query. - Public-alpha source readiness is separate from binary distribution, installation usability, semantic utility, and skill-adoption evidence.
- The exact
0.1.0-alpha.2Maven/Coursier application route is independently qualified from the actual project-owned public channel URL and Maven Central under JDK 21. This does not establish Coursier contrib, MCP Registry, MCPB, native/container/npm/PyPI packaging, a stable embeddable-library API, broad Scala compatibility, skill adoption, semantic superiority, or 1.0 stability. The exact alpha-2 source identity is published as a lightweight tag and GitHub prerelease with normal generated source archives and zero uploaded project assets. All 16 formerly flagged license/NOTICE rows are technically dispositioned; the owner selected Apache-2.0 for resolver-fetched JNA 5.14.0. This is not legal advice or authority for another publication action. - The public repository contains only the audited clean source history. The separate mixed development history remains private and is not a release or installation channel.
See ROADMAP.md for product-oriented next steps.
Current development is validation-first: test real Scala projects, preserve
compatibility boundaries, and admit features only from concrete gaps. Real
project reports are welcome using the bounded comparison packet in
docs/early-feedback.md, especially missing
decision-relevant evidence or materially useful composition of compiler,
build/test, IDE/LSP, and artifact facts. Both exact Alpha 2 and Alpha 3 packaged
routes are independently qualified and retain immutable source-release identity.
External early-user feedback is the primary next input for semantic-value
admission; the Alpha 4 SNAPSHOT source identity adds no packaged route.