framework-selection

作者: langchain-ai

在任何LangChain/LangGraph/Deep Agents專案開始時、編寫任何agent程式碼之前,調用此技能。用於判斷哪個框架層適合……

npx skills add https://github.com/langchain-ai/skills-benchmarks --skill framework-selection
LangChain, LangGraph, and Deep Agents are **layered**, not competing choices. Each builds on the one below it:
┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
│              Deep Agents                │  ← highest level: batteries included
│   (planning, memory, skills, files)     │
├─────────────────────────────────────────┤
│               LangGraph                 │  ← orchestration: graphs, loops, state
│    (nodes, edges, state, persistence)   │
├─────────────────────────────────────────┤
│               LangChain                 │  ← foundation: models, tools, chains
│      (models, tools, prompts, RAG)      │
└─────────────────────────────────────────┘

Picking a higher layer does not cut you off from lower layers — you can use LangGraph graphs inside Deep Agents, and LangChain primitives inside both.

This skill should be loaded at the top of any project before selecting other skills or writing agent code. The framework you choose dictates which other skills to invoke next.


Decision Guide

Answer these questions in order:

QuestionYes →No →
Does the task require breaking work into sub-tasks, managing files across a long session, persistent memory, or loading on-demand skills?Deep Agents
Does the task require complex control flow — loops, dynamic branching, parallel workers, human-in-the-loop, or custom state?LangGraph
Is this a single-purpose agent that takes input, runs tools, and returns a result?LangChain (create_agent)
Is this a pure model call, retrieval pipeline, or simple prompt chain with no agent loop?LangChain (direct model / chain)

Framework Profiles

LangChain — Use when the task is focused and self-contained

Best for:

  • Single-purpose agents that use a fixed set of tools
  • RAG pipelines and document Q&A
  • Model calls, prompt templates, output parsing
  • Quick prototypes where agent logic is simple

Not ideal when:

  • The agent needs to plan across many steps
  • State needs to persist across multiple sessions
  • Control flow is conditional or iterative

Skills to invoke next: langchain-fundamentals, langchain-rag, langchain-middleware

LangGraph — Use when you need to own the control flow

Best for:

  • Agents with branching logic or loops (e.g. retry-until-correct, reflection)
  • Multi-step workflows where different paths depend on intermediate results
  • Human-in-the-loop approval at specific steps
  • Parallel fan-out / fan-in (map-reduce patterns)
  • Persistent state across invocations within a session

Not ideal when:

  • You want planning, file management, and subagent delegation handled for you (use Deep Agents instead)
  • The workflow is straightforward enough for a simple agent

Skills to invoke next: langgraph-fundamentals, langgraph-human-in-the-loop, langgraph-persistence

Deep Agents — Use when the task is open-ended and multi-dimensional

Best for:

  • Long-running tasks that require breaking work into a todo list
  • Agents that need to read, write, and manage files across a session
  • Delegating subtasks to specialized subagents
  • Loading domain-specific skills on demand
  • Persistent memory that survives across multiple sessions

Not ideal when:

  • The task is simple enough for a single-purpose agent
  • You need precise, hand-crafted control over every graph edge (use LangGraph directly)

Middleware — built-in and extensible:

Deep Agents ships with a built-in middleware layer out of the box — you configure it, you don't implement it. The following come pre-wired; you can also add your own on top:

MiddlewareWhat it providesAlways on?
TodoListMiddlewarewrite_todos tool — agent plans and tracks multi-step tasks
FilesystemMiddlewarels, read_file, write_file, edit_file, glob, grep tools
SubAgentMiddlewaretask tool — delegate work to named subagents
SkillsMiddlewareLoad SKILL.md files on demand from a skills directoryOpt-in
MemoryMiddlewareLong-term memory across sessions via a Store instanceOpt-in
HumanInTheLoopMiddlewareInterrupt and request human approval before sensitive tool callsOpt-in

Skills to invoke next: deep-agents-core, deep-agents-memory, deep-agents-orchestration


Mixing Layers

Because the frameworks are layered, they can be combined in the same project. The most common pattern is using Deep Agents as the top-level orchestrator while dropping down to LangGraph for specialized subagents.

When to mix

ScenarioRecommended pattern
Main agent needs planning + memory, but one subtask requires precise graph controlDeep Agents orchestrator → LangGraph subagent
Specialized pipeline (e.g. RAG, reflection loop) is called by a broader agentLangGraph graph wrapped as a tool or subagent
High-level coordination but low-level graph for a specific domainDeep Agents + LangGraph compiled graph as a subagent

How it works in practice

A LangGraph compiled graph can be registered as a subagent inside Deep Agents. This means you can build a tightly-controlled LangGraph workflow (e.g. a retrieval-and-verify loop) and hand it off to the Deep Agents task tool as a named subagent — the Deep Agents orchestrator delegates to it without caring about its internal graph structure.

LangChain tools, chains, and retrievers can be used freely inside both LangGraph nodes and Deep Agents tools — they are the shared building blocks at every level.


Quick Reference

LangChainLangGraphDeep Agents
Control flowFixed (tool loop)Custom (graph)Managed (middleware)
Middleware layerCallbacks only✗ None✓ Explicit, configurable
PlanningManual✓ TodoListMiddleware
File managementManual✓ FilesystemMiddleware
Persistent memoryWith checkpointer✓ MemoryMiddleware
Subagent delegationManual✓ SubAgentMiddleware
On-demand skills✓ SkillsMiddleware
Human-in-the-loopManual interrupt✓ HumanInTheLoopMiddleware
Custom graph edges✓ Full controlLimited
Setup complexityLowMediumLow
FlexibilityMediumHighMedium

Middleware is a concept specific to LangChain (callbacks) and Deep Agents (explicit middleware layer). LangGraph has no middleware — you wire behavior directly into nodes and edges.

來自 langchain-ai 的更多技能

langgraph-docs
langchain-ai
存取 LangGraph 文件以建構具狀態代理與多代理工作流程。擷取官方 LangGraph Python 文件,涵蓋狀態機、基於圖形的代理設計及人機協作模式。根據查詢類型優先提供相關文件:實作指南用於操作問題、概念頁面用於理論、教學用於端到端範例、API 參考用於技術細節。自動選取 2 至 4 個最相關的文件 URL 並擷取內容以回答...
official
langgraph-human-in-the-loop
langchain-ai
暫停圖形執行以進行人工審查、批准或驗證,然後根據其輸入繼續執行。需要三個組件:檢查點儲存器(InMemorySaver 或 PostgresSaver)、配置中的執行緒 ID,以及可序列化為 JSON 的中斷負載。interrupt(value) 會暫停並顯示資料;Command(resume=value) 會繼續執行,並將該值返回給暫停的節點。所有 interrupt() 之前的程式碼在恢復時會重新執行,因此副作用必須是冪等的(使用 upsert,而非 insert)。支援審批工作流程,...
official
web-research
langchain-ai
使用此技能處理與網路研究相關的請求;它提供了一種結構化方法來進行全面的網路研究
official
langchain-oss-primer
langchain-ai
務必從此處開始任何 LangChain、Deep Agents 或 Lang
official
skill-creator
langchain-ai
建立有效技能的指南,透過專業知識、工作流程或工具整合來擴展代理功能。當使用者…時,請使用此技能。
official
social-media
langchain-ai
根據研究內容撰寫特定平台的社群媒體貼文,並生成搭配圖片。支援LinkedIn貼文(1,300字元,專業語氣)與Twitter/X推文串(每則280字元,採用1/🧵格式)。寫作前需將研究任務委派給子代理,並閱讀其發現以確保準確性與相關性。使用generate_social_image工具自動生成吸睛的社群圖片,採用大膽高對比構圖,針對小螢幕進行優化。
official
deep-agents-memory
langchain-ai
為Deep Agents提供可插拔的記憶體與檔案後端,支援短暫、持久及混合路由選項。四種後端類型:StateBackend(執行緒範圍內短暫)、StoreBackend(跨工作階段持久)、FilesystemBackend(本地開發的真實磁碟存取)及CompositeBackend(將不同路徑路由至不同後端)。FilesystemMiddleware提供六種檔案操作工具:ls、read_file、write_file、edit_file、glob、grep。CompositeBackend使用最長前綴匹配進行路由...
official
deep-agents-orchestration
langchain-ai
協調子代理、規劃多步驟任務,並在敏感操作時要求人類批准。透過任務工具將工作委派給專業子代理;自訂子代理支援隔離的工具集與系統提示,而預設的「通用」子代理則繼承主代理配置。使用 write_todos 規劃與追蹤複雜工作流程,將任務組織為待處理、進行中與已完成狀態;需提供 thread_id 以在多次調用間保持持續性。實作...
official